‘A bus is more annoying than a train’: Sydney commuters on the Bankstown line adjust amid wait for metro

By The Guardian (World News) | Created at 2024-09-30 02:45:11 | Updated at 2024-09-30 05:24:08 2 hours ago
Truth

As Anna Masood and Esmeralda Quintal waited for their train replacement buses, their patience began to wear thin as it began sprinkling.

They were waiting for an express bus to Sydenham, from where they would be taking the metro into the CBD, but they got frustrated after two all-stops buses passed them.

“We had two buses come here within 30 seconds of each other, but that means another bus won’t be here for a while. Why are they coming together, and doesn’t that mean there will be more time before the next one?” Masood said.

“That’s the problem here, buses are more inconsistent than trains, they’re more beholden to traffic. There will be a good outcome to this, they just need to work it out.”

Esmeralda Quintal and Anna Masood at bus stop
‘Buses are more inconsistent than trains, they’re more beholden to traffic.’ Esmeralda Quintal and Anna Masood wait for a bus at Punchbowl. Photograph: Blake Sharp-Wiggins/The Guardian
Buses
The buses are free but only go so far as Sydenham, before commuters will need to jump on to a train or Metro to get into the city. Photograph: Blake Sharp-Wiggins/The Guardian

As she was speaking, an express bus turned up, and she climbed aboard alongside the waiting commuters at the temporary train replacement bus station set up in Punchbowl.

The temporary stops litter the Bankstown line, which covers various suburbs in Sydney’s south and inner west, including Belmore, Campsie, Canterbury, Dulwich Hill and Marrickville.

The train line was formally shut down on Monday, to allow for work to begin converting the 130-year-old train line into a metro service, that will allow for driverless trains into the city every four minutes during peak hour.

Thousands of residents who depend on the train line will now need to shift over to the buses, which the NSW government has promised will be able to service all the passengers along the train line.

The buses are free and will remain so for the duration of the conversion, but only go so far as Sydenham before commuters will need to jump on to a train or metro to get into the city.

Timelapse: ride the new Sydney Metro from Central to Sydenham, in under 90 seconds - video

The T3 Bankstown line is also the only line to be shut down and converted into a metro line. The Chatswood to Sydenham line that opened earlier this year did not bring about a shut down of any train line.

And riding alongside the passengers, it was clear there were more buses than could be expected, with a number turning up in quick succession at every stop, many within minutes of each other.

“It will be a bit inconvenient, but I can see there are a lot of buses coming quite frequently, so it could be tolerable,” Ryan Ngo said.

Ryan Ngo on the bus
‘These metros will be good for the area, it should be much faster. Or at least I hope so.’ Ryan Ngo hopes the changes will be worth it. Photograph: Blake Sharp-Wiggins/The Guardian

He was on his way to his job as a kitchen hand at a coffee shop in the CBD, and he said he felt like the changes would be worth it.

skip past newsletter promotion

“It will be worth the wait, these metros will be good for the area, it should be much faster. Or at least I hope so.”

“You have to do what you have to do,” is how Janine Hro put it.

The changes are adding over 20 minutes to her commute from Belmore in Wynyard, but she remained positive about the shift to buses.

“Look, we don’t have a choice in it, and the buses seem to come quite often, so it’s manageable for now.”

Janine Hro waits for the bus at Belmore Station
‘You have to do what you have to do’ … Janine Hro waits for the bus at Belmore station. Photograph: Blake Sharp-Wiggins/The Guardian
Passengers get off buses
The temporary stops litter the Bankstown line, which covers various suburbs in Sydney’s south and inner west, including Belmore, Campsie, Canterbury, Dulwich Hill and Marrickville. Photograph: Blake Sharp-Wiggins/The Guardian

Much like many of the passengers, Therese Manuel had to wake up much earlier than she would have wanted, and depended on coffee to keep her going.

“It’s all a bit annoying to be honest. I understand why they are doing it, I understand the need for a metro, but you can’t deny that a bus is more annoying than a train.”

“Plus, a train took me direct to my destination, whereas there is a change I have to do now to get to the city.”

Asked how she feels about having to wake up earlier, Manuel just shook her head.

“Not good, it’s not good. These metro trains better be fast.”

Read Entire Article