Early Reviews Of You Can See Everything Are Stressing Me Out

Within hours of its theatrical release, You Can See Everything has shot to the top of every significant media ranking website there is. At the time of publication, it’s sitting at a perfect 100-percent Fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes, a 4.7 stars average on Letterboxd, and a 98 metascore on Metacritic, putting it at number 26 on that site’s best movies of all time. You Can See Everything pits surrealist Nathan Fielder against Theranos con-artist Elizabeth Holmes in a Lying Liars Who Lie-off disguised as a documentary.

According to early reviews, it’s so good it’s scary.

I’m legit scared to see it, fearing whatever tricks of the mind Nathan Fielder pulls will irrevocably damage my psyche. I’ve seen both seasons of The Rehearsal, so I know that’s a damn sure bet to make.

I was admittedly having audible reactions to You Can See Everything, so much so that I got a dirty look from the guy in the row ahead of me but like idk how u can see some of that shit and not have an audible reaction

— Jared Gilman (@realJaredGilman) October 16, 2026

really don't think I will mix up scrambled eggs the same ever again… highly recommend going to You Can See Everything, and try your best to come in "blind" as it will enhance your movie-going experience… would be shocked if it isn't a Oscar Best Picture finalist this year

— CJ (@CJLandes) October 16, 2026

still thinking about you can see everything… i’m sitting here asking my coworker if you can ever truly know someone

— mason (@hochl0re) October 16, 2026

I’m even scared to skim reviews, afraid they might divulge the trick I feel in my disquieted spirit is coming that will totally upset the balance of what or who the audience is supposed to believe. Read them at your peril. Browse social media at your peril for spoilers are afoot. Do whatever you can to shorten the time between the movie’s release and you seeing it while the thrilling uncertainty of it all still remains. But judging from what people are saying online, it might be hard to see it at all with theaters selling out nationwide, in markets big and small.

©

My shitty town’s theater isn’t playing You Can See Everything I’m about to crash out

— pj🍒 (@spookybongwater) October 16, 2026

theaters in suburban ohio being fully sold out for you can see everything is so nuts

— zoë (@zoeloveshouses) October 16, 2026

I, too, live in suburban Ohio and can confirm that the first two Friday showings of the movie at the nearest theater to me playing it were sold out. According to Deadline, the movie’s already made $1.75 million from its Thursday night opening. Not bad for production company A24, which has back-to-back hits on its hands after the outstanding and surreal Primetime released last month.